News Supreme court lawfully quashed Senator Kalu’s conviction – SAN


- Advertisment -

Supreme court lawfully quashed Senator Kalu’s conviction – SAN

News Supreme court lawfully quashed Senator Kalu’s conviction – SAN
Lawyers, social critics, Aba residents and civil society groups on Thursday lauded the 12-year prison sentence handed down to ex-Governor Orji Kalu of Abia by a Federal High Court in Lagos.

Mr Abiodun Owonikoko, a Senior Advocate of Nigeria (SAN), yesterday said that the Supreme Court lawfully quashed the conviction and 12-year imprisonment of former Abia State Governor, Dr Orji Uzor-Kalu.

Owonikoko, while reacting to the judgment of the apex court, said the Federal High Court in Lagos which last December 5 found Kalu guilty of stealing about N7.1billion from the Abia State Treasury, gave a technically flawed judgment.

He said the trial judge, Justice Mohammed Idris’ decision to continue presiding over Kalu’s case after his elevation to the Court of Appeal was contentious and likely to be overturned on appeal, just like the apex court did.

He reacts in a Facebook post after the Supreme Court ordered a retrial of Kalu’s case, Owonikoko said: “We always knew that the judgment of the trial court was technically flawed (not on the merit though) hence the order for trial de novo (afresh ).

“It was easy to predict that it might not survive on appeal based on that snag of the judge coming back from a court of appeal to deliver judgment on a criminal trial that he did not conclude before his elevation.

“Who delivered the judgment at the trial court? Was it Idris J (as he had then ceased to be)? – or Idris JCA (Justice of the Court of Appeal) as he had already become at the material time?”

Owonikoko noted that the Administration of Criminal Justice Act (ACJA) gave a judicial officer that leeway, but that “it requires a constitutional amendment to validate it.

“Unfortunately we did not have such amendment at the material time and sadly, till date.”

He suggested that the EFCC should have opposed the continuation of Kalu’s trial before Justice Idris after his elevation to the Court of Appeal.

“The lynch mob mentality of conviction by whatever means misled EFCC to continue with the trial after Idris JCA had been appointed a Justice of the Court of Appeal. ”

“The injustice of the judgment is made all the more glaring when the erstwhile convict has had to serve time in prison whereas he is yet to be convicted; only to face new a trial for the same offences without a chance for compensation for the time served (wrongfully) in the event he is eventually found NOT GUILTY.

All hope is not lost however; the legislature can be approached to do the needful and render this judgment academic for future cases,” Owonikoko said.

The apex court yesterday in a unanimous decision by a seven-man panel led by Justice Amina Augie, voided Kalu’s December 2019 trial for stealing about N7.1billion from the Abia State treasury.

It held that the Federal High Court in Lagos acted without jurisdiction when it convicted Kalu, his firm, Slok Nigeria Ltd and former Director of Finance in Abia State, Jones Udeogu.

It held that trial judge Justice Mohammed Idris was no longer a judge of the Federal High Court as at the time he sat and delivered the judgement that convicted the defendants for allegedly stealing about N7.1billion from Abia state treasury.

According to the Supreme Court, Justice Idris, having been elevated to the Court of Appeal before then, lacked the powers to return to sit as a High Court Judge.

It held that the Fiat that was issued to him by the Court of Appeal President pursuant to section 396(7) of the Administration of Criminal Justice Act was unconstitutional.

The apex court vacated the judgement that convicted the defendants and ordered fresh trial.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Recent Updates

Thiago Silva not at Chelsea to ‘visit tourist sites’

Thiago Silva is eager to point out that he is not at Chelsea to “visit tourist sites” and “go...

Partizan Belgrade’s Sadiq Umar bags sixth goal of the season

Sadiq Umar was on target for Partizan Belgrade in their 2 – 1 victory over Backa Backa Palanka in...

Frank Lampard casts doubt over Victor Moses future at Chelsea

Frank Lampard insists Victor Moses will not be part of his squad for Tuesday’s Carabao Cup clash with Tottenham...

Nigerian traders in Ghana attempting suicide over maltreatment

Some Nigerian traders in Ghana are considering suicide as option, following rising cases of frustrations, biting hunger and sad...
- Advertisement -

Four die, 12 injured in Lagos-Ibadan expressway crash

Four persons on Monday died, while 12 others sustained various degrees of injuries in a lone accident involving a...

Serie A side Genoa confirm 14 virus cases

Genoa have announced that 14 members of their match squad, believed to include 8-10 players, tested positive for COVID-19...
- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you